Ideology

Populism

Populism

Populism is most often defined, following political scientist Cas Mudde's influential ideational approach, as a thin-centered ideology holding that society is ultimately separated into two homogeneous and antagonistic groups, the pure people and the corrupt elite, and that politics should above all express the general will of the people. Because it makes no independent claim about the proper scope of the state, the market or moral life, this thin ideology typically attaches itself to a fuller host ideology of the left or right, producing left-wing and right-wing populisms that otherwise share little beyond the people-versus-elite frame and an appeal to a single, unified popular will against pluralist and institutional constraints. Two rival scholarly traditions define the same word differently. A political-strategic approach, associated with Kurt Weyland, instead defines populism as a strategy through which a personalistic leader seeks or exercises government power based on direct, unmediated and de-institutionalized support from a large number of mostly unorganized followers, treating organizational form rather than professed ideas as the defining trait. A discursive approach, associated with Ernesto Laclau, treats populism not as a species of ideology or strategy at all but as a political logic that constructs the very category of the people by chaining together otherwise unrelated social demands against a common adversary, present in principle in movements across the ideological spectrum.

Populism is defined three incompatible ways in the scholarly literature, recorded here as a live dispute rather than folded into one account: the ideational approach (Cas Mudde), the political-strategic approach (Kurt Weyland), and the discursive approach (Ernesto Laclau). The working description below follows the ideational approach, the most widely used of the three in comparative politics; see the attached dissent for Laclau's own challenge to taking it as the default.
Facts
Founding Context
The word entered political usage independently in two nineteenth century contexts. The Russian Narodniki (populists) of the 1860s and 1870s were agrarian socialist intellectuals who idealized the peasant commune as a distinctly Russian road to socialism bypassing capitalism. The United States People's Party, an agrarian and labor coalition, adopted the populist label on its founding in Omaha in 1892 and ran James B. Weaver for president that year on a platform of free silver, a graduated income tax and public control of the railroads. Twentieth and twenty-first century usage generalized the word far beyond either origin, applying it to a recurring political style found across Latin America, Europe and elsewhere rather than to one movement or party family. 1
Disputed
Origin Year
1892 1
1892 marks the founding of the United States People's Party in Omaha, the movement usually credited with putting the word populism into English-language political use. The Russian Narodnik movement used the underlying concept from the 1860s onward, and which of the two, if either, should count as populism's true origin is not settled by the sources.
Classification
Ideological Family or Spectrum Position
Populism 1
Connections

Advocated By

Andrew Jackson, Political Figures

Why this is disputed. Jacksonian democracy is frequently characterised by historians as an early expression of American populism (anti-elite rhetoric, appeal to the common man, direct majoritarian legitimacy), a later historiographical reading rather than a contemporary self-description.

ANO 2011, Institutions
Source ANO 2011 (Wikipedia)
Source Bhumjaithai Party (Wikipedia)
Source Brothers of Italy (Wikipedia)
Source Defenders of the Homeland (Colombia) (Wikipedia)
Source Direction - Social Democracy (Wikipedia)
Source Estonian Centre Party (Wikipedia)
Source Law and Justice (Wikipedia)
Source National Regeneration Movement (Wikipedia)
Source National Resistance Movement (Wikipedia)
Source Republican Party (United States) (Wikipedia)
Source Servant of the People (Wikipedia)
Source Tisza Party (Wikipedia)

Associated With

Populism's appeal to a single, undivided will of the people bears directly on the older tension between majority rule and the institutional and constitutional constraints meant to protect minorities and dissent from it.

Source Cas Mudde and Cristobal Rovira Kaltwasser, Populism: A Very Short Introduction (Oxford University Press, 2017)
Nationalism, Ideologies

Populist movements frequently fuse with nationalist appeals to a bounded, culturally defined people, though the combination is common rather than definitional; populism has also taken cosmopolitan and left-internationalist forms.

Source Cas Mudde and Cristobal Rovira Kaltwasser, Populism: A Very Short Introduction (Oxford University Press, 2017)

Held Differently

Peronism, Ideologies

Peronism is widely classified in comparative politics as a paradigmatic Latin American populist movement, combining nationalist and redistributive appeals with a charismatic leader-followers relationship.

Sources
1. Cas Mudde and Cristobal Rovira Kaltwasser, Populism: A Very Short Introduction (Oxford University Press, 2017)
Oxford University Press
  • Ideological family, description
    Populism is most often defined, following political scientist Cas Mudde's influential ideational approach, as a thin-centered ideology holding that society is ultimately separated into two homogeneous and antagonistic groups, the pure people and the corrupt elite, and that politics should above all express the general will of the people.
  • Associated With: Nationalism
  • Associated With: Majority Rule and Minority Rights
Republican Party (United States) (Wikipedia)
Advocated By: Republican Party (United States), Lead section
Quote, Advocated By: Republican Party (United States), Lead section
The Republican Party, also known as the Grand Old Party (GOP), is a right-wing populist and neo-nationalist political party in the United States, sitting on the right-wing to far-right of the political spectrum.
View the Source
National Regeneration Movement (Wikipedia)
Advocated By: National Regeneration Movement, Lead section
Quote, Advocated By: National Regeneration Movement, Lead section
Morena's platform combines elements of left-wing populism and progressivism.
View the Source
Brothers of Italy (Wikipedia)
Advocated By: Brothers of Italy, Lead section
Quote, Advocated By: Brothers of Italy, Lead section
Brothers of Italy (Italian: Fratelli d'Italia, FdI) is a national-conservative and right-wing populist political party in Italy, that is currently the country's ruling party.
View the Source
Bhumjaithai Party (Wikipedia)
Advocated By: Bhumjaithai Party, Lead section
Quote, Advocated By: Bhumjaithai Party, Lead section
Bhumjaithai Party (BJT; Thai: พรรคภูมิใจไทย; RTGS: Phak Phumchaithai, lit. 'Thai Proud Party') is a major conservative populist political party in Thailand.
View the Source
ANO 2011 (Wikipedia)
Advocated By: ANO 2011, Lead section
Quote, Advocated By: ANO 2011, Lead section
ANO (lit. 'Yes'), registered as ANO 2011, is a right-wing populist political party in the Czech Republic led by businessman and current Prime Minister Andrej Babiš.
View the Source
Tisza Party (Wikipedia)
Advocated By: Tisza Party, Lead section
Quote, Advocated By: Tisza Party, Lead section
The Respect and Freedom Party, commonly known by its Hungarian abbreviations Tisza Party and TISZA, is a conservative, centre-right, pro-European, and populist political party in Hungary.
View the Source
Direction - Social Democracy (Wikipedia)
Advocated By: Direction - Social Democracy, Lead section
Quote, Advocated By: Direction - Social Democracy, Lead section
Direction, Social Democracy (Slovak: Smer, sociálna demokracia), also commonly referred to as Smer, is a left-wing populist and left-wing nationalist political party in Slovakia led by its founder and incumbent prime minister, Robert Fico.
View the Source
Servant of the People (Wikipedia)
Advocated By: Servant of the People, Ideology and position, populist description
Quote, Advocated By: Servant of the People, Ideology and position, populist description
It is positioned in the centre on the political spectrum, while its political ideology has been described as populist, as well as liberal.
View the Source
Defenders of the Homeland (Colombia) (Wikipedia)
Advocated By: Defenders of the Homeland, Lead, ideology
Quote, Advocated By: Defenders of the Homeland, Lead, ideology
It is described as an anti-establishment and populist movement.
View the Source
National Resistance Movement (Wikipedia)
Advocated By: National Resistance Movement, Ideological shift, populism
Quote, Advocated By: National Resistance Movement, Ideological shift, populism
Currently, the party supports nationalism, social conservatism, right-wing populism, and economic liberalism.
View the Source
Law and Justice (Wikipedia)
Advocated By: Law and Justice, Lead, ideology populist
Quote, Advocated By: Law and Justice, Lead, ideology populist
is a right-wing populist and national-conservative political party
View the Source
Estonian Centre Party (Wikipedia)
Advocated By: Estonian Centre Party, Lead
Quote, Advocated By: Estonian Centre Party, Lead
is a populist political party in Estonia
View the Source
Dissenting Readings (1 dissenting reading)
Description

Ernesto Laclau, in On Populist Reason (2005), rejected the ideational approach's treatment of populism as one ideology, however thin, among others, arguing instead that populism is a political logic: the process by which heterogeneous social demands left unmet by an existing order are chained together into a single chain of equivalence against a common adversary, condensed into the name of a unified people. On this reading populism is not a doctrine with fixed content a movement either holds or does not, but a way of constructing political identity available in principle to movements of any ideological coloring, so measuring how populist a party is by counting its stated beliefs, as the ideational approach does, mistakes the symptom for the mechanism.

A dissenting reading, from Ernesto LaclauErnesto Laclau, On Populist Reason (Verso, 2005), Verso
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share a thought.
Reader Challenges (0)
No disputes yet. Spotted an error or a better source? Open the first one.

Political Atlas

How Power Is Arranged
Sign In
Text size
100%
Theme